OSCAR RACE 2008
commentary by Nathaniel R

Approximately days since Hollywood's High Holy Night

Please note: nomination statistics reflect the category being discussed only.
Some crew members work in multiple field. Just as writer-director is a common
hyphenate so isproduction designer-costumer, etcetera
costume design has its own page

 

Cinematography

I scored 4/5 in my predictions. My own preferences line up 2/5. I was right to assume that Revolutionary Road might be snubbed (preventing a second consecutive double nomination for still un-Oscared Roger Deakins) and I was right to assume that Changeling (which I had in 7th place) might have a real shot. But it's still a surprise. Tom Stern, Eastwood's preferred DP has never even been nominated when an Eastwood picture has made it to the Best Picture lineup so it's a surprise. A pleasant one for Stern undoubtedly.

I believe that Benjamin Button has a chance to win this here's why... but I'm predicting Slumdog because it feels like a sweeper

What's your preference? (not prediction)


Changeling
Tom Stern
1st nomination!

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Claudio Miranda
1st nomination!
The Dark Knight
Wally Pfister
3rd nomination
The Reader
Chris Menges
4th nom / 2 wins

and Roger Deakins
8th nomination
Slumdog Millionaire
Anthony Dod Mantle
1st nom & win !
BAFTA & SATELLITE nominee.
ASC, Satellite & BAFTA NOM
selling points:
Looks epic. Theatrical lighting (performance), scale, and working with f/x
ASC & BAFTA NOM
selling points:
this franchise, the Nolan/Pfister track record
ASC & BAFTA NOM
selling points:
gorgeous and emotionally attuned lighting. Range within the movie
ASC & BAFTA NOM / NSFC & NYFCC winner
selling points:

Very colorful and dramatically lit. People love the film

 

Art Direction

I scored 3/5 in my predictions. My own preferences line up only 1/5 so I'm rooting for Benjamin Button in this particular category. The art director's branch of the Academy really opened the doors for new members now with a ton of first time nominees. Welcome to the party!

My guess is that CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON wins this but I suppose The Duchess is the alternate should Benjamin Button support be much lighter than its nomination tally suggests.

Changeling
James Murakami
1st nomination!
Gary Fettis
2nd nomination

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Donald Graham Burt
1st nom & win!
Victor Solfo

1st nom & win!
The Dark Knight
Nathan Crowley
2nd nomination
Peter Lando
1st nomination!
The Duchess
Michael Carlin
1st nomination!
Rebecca Alleway
1st nomination!

Revolutionary Road
Kristi Zea
1st nomination!
Debra Shutt

1st nomination!
ADG (Period) Memorable locations such as the chicken ranch and the fact that it's a period piece with the Clint Eastwood Oscar magnetism...
ADG (Period)
He usually does contemporary pictures but for this multitime period drama he still manages to wow...
ADG (Fantasy) Gotham City gets yet creepier. They like Chris Nolan's team of right hand men
   

 

Film Editing

I scored 5/5 in my predictions... but the editors tend to be easy to predict, tending to go with whatever the Best Picture frontrunners are assumed to be. My own preferences line up only 1/5 so I'm rooting for Milk...

I predictt this is an easy get for the very visible frantic editing of Slumdog Millionaire. (I never really understand the choices the editor's branch makes each year) with The Dark Knight as the spoiler if they feel like Slumdog has won plenty already.

Slumdog Millionaire
Chris Dickens
1st nom & win !
Frost/Nixon
Daniel P Hill & Mike Hill
4th nom / 1 win
The Dark Knight Lee Smith
2nd nomination
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Kirk Baxter & Angus Wall
1st nomination!
Milk
Elliot Graham and Gus Van Sant
1st nomination!
ACE NOM
ACE NOM
ACE NOM
ACE NOM
ACE NOM

 

Visual Effects

I scored 3/3 in my predictions (it was easy - I ain't bragging) and this is 2/3 with my preferences. I'm rooting for a win for Benjamin Button, which was such a wow effects wise. And unless the Batman fans within AMPAS are angry enough to vote for The Dark Knight everywhere... I predict it CCoBB has this.

Iron Man
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
The Dark Knight

 

Best MakeUp

I scored only 1/3 in my predictions (makeup is always tough to forsee) and this is 2/3 with my preferences. I'm rooting for a win for The Dark Knight for that iconic Joker interpretation.Benjamin Button generally looked great and realistic but I don't understand why Cate Blanchett was made up to look like a 110 year old when her daughter was only 40?

That said I imagine Benjamin Button wins this without much trouble

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
The Dark Knight
Hellboy 2
aging backwards. a visual treat... and it didn't get disqualified for f/x tweaks which says something
do you wanna know how he got those scars?
Surprise. Certainly it's fine work but why did they ignore the first film when they created the characters?

 

 

Last Year's Race