Yes No Maybe So: "Downton Abbey"
Wednesday, May 22, 2019 at 8:00AM
NATHANIEL R in Adaptations, Downton Abbey, Imelda Staunton, Maggie Smith, Matthew Goode, Michelle Dockery, TV, Yes No Maybe So, sequels

Welcome to Downton Abbey

The new trailer for Downton Abbey has arrived. Or two new trailers. Or perhaps one of them is older... well, we lose track these days as films have so many promos and so many versions of each trailer. At any rate it's officially time to get excited about the big screen union of everyone's favourite early 20th century posh costume drama. Let's do the Yes No Maybe So thing after the jump...

THE TRAILER(s) IN QUESTION

YES

Oh here we go...

• The "cast" card says it all really. Instead of actors names, an ingenous touch -- just the character names: Lord Grantham, Lady Grantham, Lady Mary Talbot, Henry Talbot, The Dowager Countess of Grantham, Tom Branson, Lady Pelham, Lord Pelham, Lady Merton, Lord Merton, Thomas Barrow, Mr Carson, Mrs Patmore, Mrs Hughes, Mr Bates, Mrs Bates, Daisy Mason, Andy Parker, Mr Molesley, Miss Baxter. Iconic characters, well some of them at least, at this point after six seasons and a decade in the public consciousness.

• As per usual peaks at Dame Maggie Smith getting the best lines at the Dowager Countess. Especially love that bit where she needs help to get up after a curtsy. Or in the other trailer where she and Lady Merton (the former Isabel Crawley, played by Penelope Wilton) square off.

• Part of the joy of Downton Abbey (and all posh costume dramas, really) is the clothes and environments and they're definitely aware of that, showing off in the trailers. 


• About half of the beloved characters get their own little visual intros in the trailers, but Carson (Jim Carter) gets pride of place with his own roping-back-in to the narrative "I'll be there in the morning" since he had been forced to retire at the end of Season 6.

• The plot appears to involve a kind of turf war between royal staff, and the familiar Downton staff which could be lots of fun in an upstairs/downstairs/uppity-downstairs kind of way. 

I never argue. I explain.

• New characters! The great Imelda Staunton has arrived to face off with Maggie Smith. We will take one feature film spin-off with just the two of them, please. (Trivia note: Imelda Staunton is actually married to Jim Carter who played "Carson" all throughout the series)

• Tom Branson looks to be getting yet another class-inappropriate romance. But we love to look longingly at Allen Leech so that's alright by us. Speaking of drool-worthy couples: Michelle Dockery & Matthew Goode was such a great match of ridiculously uppercrust hotness in that final season that it'll be nice to see it more fleshed out with one more go-round.

NO

What?

• Look, we hate to support the full-blown death of cinema by "brands" but this is Downton Abbey so we have to cry uncle, or at least ring the bell for uncle politely. But we might feel crappy about doing it, if the movie isn't at least as good as the worst season of the show.

• Wait where is Spratt, the Dowager Countess's butler? He was always great with Maggie Smith. It's already sad that not every character who ever appeared in that wonderful show will be included in the movie.  No zombie Matthew Crawley (Dan Stevens) or zombie Lady Sybil (Jessica Brown Findlay).

• Please note that there seems to be no plot whatsoever apart from the King & Queen coming for a visit and everyone getting really anxious about it. It is entirely posible that this is all there is as plot goes since this might just be Fan-Service: The Movie and consist of nothing more than 37 character re-introductions before the curtain call.

MAYBE SO


• Ohmygod. They're giving Thomas a romance? Is there going to be so much fan-service that they give even the formal beloved villains redemption arcs?

• This will be a very difficult balancing act to pull off. On the one hand they do need to do fan-service and give each character their due. On the other hand if there was one painfully true valid critique of the series it's that it was endlessly repetitive (What horrible thing will happen to Mr & Mrs Bates this time? What scheme will nearly backfire on Thomas and yet somehow he will manage to keep his job? In what way will icy Lady Mary's heart show itself?  What humiliating thing will happen to ? 

Regardless of worries that this will be fun fanservice at best and a giant commercial for its past glory at worst, I'm not even going to pretend I won't be there on opening night. A total yes for me.

How about you? Are you ready for a very modern 1927 in movie theaters this fall?!? Will you be there with your entire entourage (maids, cooks, underbutlers, and footmen) in September?

Article originally appeared on The Film Experience (http://thefilmexperience.net/).
See website for complete article licensing information.