AFI Fest: “Ray Gunn” misfires while “Queen at Sea” reigns supreme
Wednesday, October 28, 2026 at 1:30PM
Brian Rector in AFI Film Festival, Anna Calder-Marshall, Brad Bird, Film Reviews, Juliette Binoche, Lance Hammer, Queen at Sea, Ray Gunn, Reviews, Tom Courtenay, animation, film festivals

by Brian Rector

Late in the festival season, AFI Fest often brings an opportunity for Los Angelinos to catch up on titles that received buzz earlier in the year while bringing a few new films to the forefront. For instance, Brad Bird’s new animated movie Ray Gunn had its west coast red carpet premiere on the final day of the festival. On the other hand, Lance Hammer's Queen at Sea followed from its Berlin Film Festival debut, where it won a cadre of Silver Bears, including for its director and the Best Supporting Acting trophy for two of its performers, Tom Courtenay and Anna Calder-Marshall...

 

RAY GUNN, Brad Bird 

It’s been eight years since Brad Bird brought us The Incredibles 2, Pixar’s highest-grossing film to date. Ray Gunn is his first directorial effort since and knowing the creative outputs he has gifted us over the years, it was especially exciting to hear that he was making a noir mystery, playing in a genre that rarely gets its due in modern cinema. His take is futuristic, but many elements feel modern-day, especially the focus on artificial intelligence. In this world, aliens are commonplace, flying cars are the most frequent mode of travel and society is largely run by a combination of corporate heads and gangsters that speak like 1940s cinematic throwbacks. All in all, an interesting clash of genres, but that’s one of Ray Gunn’s issues: too many ideas combine to ultimately leave the most promising details unexplored. 

Ray Gunn, the character, is a down-on-his-luck detective with an underappreciated alien sidekick, which is true for all aliens, who are treated as second class citizens. The othering of these characters is presented merely as a self-evident truth, and while it is mentioned at several points, the film accepts this as status quo. Ray’s case focuses on pop diva Venus Nova, whose high-profile antics have landed her in trouble on several occasions. We learn early on that her corporate sponsors are working on a much more PR-friendly AI version of herself to avoid disaster. Again, corporate rebranding of a celebrity could kick off an interesting moral quandary, but the film is more interested in noting this than addressing it with any emotional depth.

In a narrative that could be described as being about business ethics, it doesn’t help that Skydance was plastered all over the opening credits, which was met by the local audience with complete silence. Instead, hijinks ensue as the case evolves into larger twists – all of which the audience can see coming a mile away. It’s really the plot's predictable nature, when there is so much potential to explore interesting territory, that disappoints most. Bird has a talent for tapping into the personal with his animated adventures, and on that front, Ray Gunn never lands. The flick is too busy jostling from one scene to another to take the time to get under the skin of the emotional stakes it tries to set up. On paper, the concepts are engaging and there's no denying the beauty of its world's design, but the movie forgets to get the audience invested beyond that.

 

QUEEN AT SEA, Lance Hammer

Queen at Sea is an entirely different story. The film kicks off with a call made to the police when a woman played by Juliette Binoche walks in on her mother (Anna Calder-Marshall) and stepfather (Tom Courtenay) having sex. She begins screaming at her stepfather about her mom’s dementia and how she is not able to consent to what is happening. This doesn’t just relate to this specific incident, though. Writer/director Lance Hammer is using a shocking episode to help us understand a family dynamic where contrasting opinions about care become increasingly fraught as mental capacity diminishes. How can a woman in such a situation show her own desires and concerns, whith an illness attacking her brain? 

Involving the police creates a new layer of complication – Courtenay’s stepfather is the primary caregiver for his wife, but there may now be legal concerns about him having control over her. He is stubborn, insisting he can handle the situation, though it’s clear he has not come to terms with the changing reality. The man believes he can just forge ahead without making adjustments to his everyday life, but it isn't so. Binoche’s daughter is trying to put her life on hold to help, yet it's only a temporary solution and she has her own concerns to distract her away from the matriarch's care. Including a teenage daughter (Florence Hunt) that need her attention and motherly interest. There are no easy answers to the family strain as everyone is trying to find order in a life that they are no longer able to control.

Hammer’s feature debut, Ballast, received acclaim 18 years ago, and this is the first film he has made since. One of the reason Queen at Sea stands out as one of the year’s best is his ability to shift audience perspective between his principal characters – we understand everyone believes they are right and see their case, but that awareness doesn’t help resolve any of their issues. Calder-Marshall does an excellent job showing us a woman operating on instinct. And as her husband and daughter watch her for indications of lucidity or clues into how they should care, it’s too easy for them to read their own interpretations into perceived motivations.

Despite their frustrations, Binoche and Courtenay’s characters are eventually forced to realize they need to work together. Queen at Sea manages to add new layers to the story with each new problem encountered, though, and every potential problem solved leads to new complications. Family conflict resolution and matters of care are prominent themes at the movies this year – both Tangles and Tender Loving Care would make for a perfect double feature with Queen at Sea. All of the central performances are fantastic here, too, and despite the tough subject matter, getting the audience to put themselves into each character’s shoes makes the plot compelling at every turn.

Tom Courtenay was just nominated for the Gotham Award for Outstanding Supporting Performance for his work in Queen at Sea. Hopefully the awards love continues throughout the season because this is film deserves to be seen! And you can see it in limited release starting this Friday. As for Ray Gunn, it'll start streaming on Netflix December 18, just in time for the holidays.

Article originally appeared on The Film Experience (http://thefilmexperience.net/).
See website for complete article licensing information.