Welcome

The Film Experience™ was created by Nathaniel R. All material herein is written by our team. (This site is not for profit but for an expression of love for cinema & adjacent artforms.)

Follow TFE on Substackd

Powered by Squarespace
DON'T MISS THIS

OSCAR POLLS ARE UP ON EVERY CHART - vote daily!

pic | dir | screenplays | actress | actor | supp' actress | supp' actor | visuals | music | international film | animation & docs

COMMENTS
Keep TFE Strong

We're looking for 500... no 390 SubscribersIf you read us daily, please be one.  

I ♥ The Film Experience

THANKS IN ADVANCE

What'cha Looking For?
Subscribe

 

 

Index | Picture | Actress | Actor | Supp Actor | Supp ActressDirector 

Screenplays | Visuals | Music and Sound | Animation & Docs | International Film

97th Oscars. Predictions for the Films of 2024, 2025 Ceremony: March 2
 For prediction, discussion, entertainment purposes only discuss on the blog

  

AND THE NOMINEES ARE...

stats reflect producing nominations in Best Picture only. * = they have stats in other categories too

 

ANORA
Alex Coco, Samantha Quan, Sean Baker*
first nominations for all!

Sean Baker
Neon
October
6 noms

Cannes Review 
TIFF Review

previous wins: Cannes Palme d'Or, LAFCA, and regional critics awards

 

THE BRUTALIST
Nominees TBA

Brady Corbet
A24
December
10 noms

Venice Review

previous wins: NYFCC, Golden Globe Drama, and several regional critics awards

 

 

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN
Fred Berger, James Mangold* (2nd nomination , Alex Heineman first nomination!

James Mangold
Searchlight
December
8 noms

synopsis: A drama doubling as a pseudo concert film in which we meet the young "Bobby Dylan" as he meets his idols and then surpasses them in fame, going electric just when they need him to promote "folk" music. 

previous wins: none

 

CONCLAVE
Tessa Ross
Juliette Howell, Michael Jackman
first nominations for all!

Edward Berger
Focus
November
8 noms

TIFF Review

synopsis: After a Pope's unexpected death, Cardinals gather to elect his successor. Everyone has an agenda and some of them have secrets, too. 

previous wins: mostly ensemble prizes

DUNE PART TWO
Mary Parent (3rd nom), Cale Boyter and Denis Villeneuve*
(2nd nom for both)
Tanya Lapointe first nomination!

Denis Villeneuve)
Warner Bros
March 
5 noms

Theatrical Review

synopsis: In this sequel Paul Atreides becomes a Messiah of sorts to the  Freemen army in their struggle against the ruling family over control of their homeland and is precious resources

previous wins: a few regional critics awards

 

EMILIA PEREZ
Pascal Caucheteux and Jacques Audiard*
first nominations for both!

Jacques Audiard
Netflix
November
13 noms

TIFF Review

Synopsis: A musical drama about a violent cartel boss reinventing her life as a charitable trans woman

previous wins: Cannes Jury Prize, EFA, and Golden Globe (Comedy or Musical)

 

I'M STILL HERE
Nominees TBA

Walter Salles
SPC
Qualifier
3 noms

TIFF Review

Synopsis: A widow seeks information and justice when her husband is disappeared by the fascist government in 1970s Brazil

previous wins:  international feature awards only

 

THE NICKEL BOYS
DeDe Gardner (8th nom | 2 wins), Jeremy Kleiner (7th nom | 2 wins), Joslyn Barnes* first nomination!

RaMell Ross
Amazon / MGM
December
2 nominations

Synopsis: A man recalls his teenager years as an unwilling student in a violent, racist, "reform" school. 

previous wins: NSFC, and a couple of critics group awards

 

THE SUBSTANCE
Nominees TBA

Coralie Fargeat
MUBI
September
5 noms

Theatrical Review

Synopsis: A celebrity seeks a black market drug to become young and "desirable" again... with terrifying results

previous wins: Cannes screenplay, 1 regional critics award

WICKED
Marc Platt (4th nom)

Jon M Chu
Universal
November
10 noms

Synopsis: A prequel and riff on The Wizard of Oz, as the Good Witch of the North and the Wicked Witch of the West meet at university and become unexpected friends. But life in Oz is not as rosy as it seems, especially for those who are "different"

previous wins: NBR and a couple of critics awards 

 

WHAT SHOULD WIN? VOTE DAILY

 

 

WHAT WAS LEFT OUT?

The precursors suggested that A Real Pain, September 5, and Sing Sing all had a decent shot at making the top ten and some optimists hoped for All That We Imagine As Light. But it wasn't to be They were crowded out by rising late year releases in critical darling Nickel Boys and the international hit I'm Still Here... the latter being the only legitimate surprise this year.

 

WHAT WILL WIN?

While Emilia Perez leads by a strong margin (13 nominations is... A LOT) we hold out hope that The Brutalist, Anora, Wicked, or Conclave (which are all much better films) can gain unexpected momentum to defeat it. That said, it's probably Emilia Perez since the industry, in particular, is obsessed. It's another reminder that Oscar voters aren't critics. Among Oscar's ten favourites this season, Emilia Perez has the lowest RT and Metacritic scores.


WHAT SHOULD WIN? NATHANIEL'S PICK

 

Anora or The Brutalist would make excellent winners for disparate reasons.

Longest to Shortest RT / MetaCritis Scores Do they pass the Bechdel Test? MPAA Ratings Nathaniel's Preference

So long they're cut up into parts....
Brutalist (214)
Dune Part Two (166)
Wicked (160)

much longer than the material warrants!
Substance (141)
Complete Unknown (141)
Nickel Boys (140)
Anora (139)

over two hours but there's a lot going on... so fine

I'm Still Here (136)
Emilia Perez (132)

Reasonable
!
Conclave (120)

keepin' it tight!
[none]

ecstatic response
Anora (93/91)
I'm Still Here (95/85)
The Brutalist (93/90)

raves

Nickel Boys (90/91)

widely liked
Conclave (93/79)
Dune Part Two (92/79)
The Substance (89/78)

well reviewed but more divisive
Wicked (88/73)
Complete Unknown (80/70)
Emilia Perez (74/71)

Superbly
Emilia Perez
I'm Still Here
Wicked

I think so... but not with flying colors
Brutalist
Dune Part Two

Definitely not.
Anora
Conclave
Complete Unknown
Nickel Boys
The Substance

Hard R
Substance
Brutalist
Anora
Emilia Perez

Soft R
Complete Unknown

PG-13
Dune Part Two
I'm Still Here
Nickel Boys

PG... which is rare for best pics now
Conclave
Wicked

(ordered by tiers)

sing hallelujah
Anora
Brutalist
Wicked

cmon get happy
Conclave
Substance
I'm Still Here

blah blah blah take all your ares away?
Complete Unknown
Dune Part Two

get ready for the judgement day
Emilia Perez
Nickel Boys

Ranked by Horniness Most likely to become a Broadway musical Death Count Ordered by US Release Date Ranked by Global Box Office

"Do you think I'm a nasty girl?"
Anora

"DTF"
The Brutalist
I'm Still Here (look at the size of that family)
Complete Unknown

"Are you that somebody?"
The Substance
Emilia Perez
Wicked

"We don't have to take our clothes off"
Dune Part Two

"No"
Conclave
Nickel Boys

 

 

via time machine... the year is 2003
Wicked

small lift to get there... 
Emilia Perez
Complete Unknown

they often try, however ill-judged the attempt
I'm still Here
Conclave
Anora


God forbid

Nickel Boys
Dune Part Two
Substance

Haunted by massacres prior to opening credits
Emilia Perez
The Brutalist

Perpetual warfare so lots
Dune Part Two

systemic frequent death but just one in narrative

Nickel Boys
I'm Still Here

one
The Substance
Complete Unknown
Conclave

possibly but far offscreen
Wicked

'the little death' only but frequently
Anora

March
Dune Part Two

September
The Substance

Oct
Conclave
Anora

Nov
Emilia Perez
Wicked

Dec
Nickel Boys
The Brutalist
Complete Unknown

Only Technically 2024 (Qualifier)
I'm Still Here

🔺 = still collecting coin 

1 🔺 Wicked ($718) 

2 Dune Part Two ($714)

3 Conclave ($84)

4 The Substance ($76)

5 🔺 A Complete Unknown ($75) 

6 Anora ($33)

7 🔺 I'm Still Here ($15) 

8 Emilia Perez ($13)

9 🔺The Brutalist ($12) 

10 🔺 Nickel Boys ($1)