Oscar History

The Film Experience™ was created by Nathaniel R. Gemini, Cinephile, Actressexual. All material herein is written and copyrighted by Nathaniel or a member of our team as noted.

Powered by Squarespace
Don't Miss This!

Smackdown 2016
Nicole vs Naomie vs Octavia vs Michelle vs Viola

What'cha Looking For?
Comment Fun

Comment Du Jour
When Actor & Actress are a package deal

"A very cool list though to be honest I wouldn’t have handed these wins to any of the pairs in these years." - Joel

"NETWORK should have easily won The Big Five. It's so weird to see 3 acting winners from a movie whose characters barely even interact with each other, if ever really. " - Craver

Keep TFE Strong

Love the Site? DONATE 

Your suscription dimes make an enormous difference to The Film Experience in terms of stability and budget to dream bigger. Consider...

I ♥ The Film Experience



Oscar Interviews
Asghar Farhadi (The Salesman)
Saroo & Sue Brierley (Lion)
Martin Butler & Bentley Dean (Tanna)
Nicole Kidman (Lion)
Denis Villeneuve (Arrival


« Happy Gabby Day | Main | Hot Docs: LGBT Films »

Review: Iron Man Three*

This review was originally posted in my column @ Towleroad

When last we saw Tony Stark he was eating shawarma in New York City with his fellow superheroes in the stinger of Marvel's The Avengers (reviewed). When we last saw Iron Man, minutes before that, he was plummeting from a cosmic wormhole to his near-death having just saved the world from an alien apocalypse. (S.H.I.E.L.D's workman's comp insurance must be pricey.) I mention Tony Stark and Iron Man separately because the franchise's new writer/director Shane Black, who previously worked with Robert Downey Jr on the underappreciated comedy Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, seems more interested in Stark than Iron Man. This is a good sign, especially for a third picture. Time to flip this tin can around.

IRON MAN THREE takes great pains to make a distinction between the impenetrable suit and the man inside it. Tony Stark's first attempt to suit up is a comic misfire since he's engineered an Iron Man suit that comes right to him when he calls. He hasn't quite worked out the speed of his flying wardrobe -imagine a metal codpiece flying 60 mph right at your Andrew Christians. The second time we see Iron Man, if I'm remembering the sequence of events correctly, Tony Stark isn't in the suit at all. He's engaging in some prankster remote control business for girlfriend Pepper Potts (Gwyneth Paltrow, wonderful in this role but haters gonna hate). MORE AFTER THE JUMP

Stay alert! Dodge those sequel dangers

The film even opens with a flashback to Tony's pre-Iron Man days, further separating the man from his iron mask. Many years earlier Tony Stark dissed sycophant nerd scientist Aldrich Killian (Guy Pearce) and seduced genius botanist Maya Hansen (Rebecca Hall) making breakthroughs in genetic healing and limb rejuvenation. Stark's actions will come with heavy consequences though we don't yet know how. Stark spells this out for us with the narrated warning that "we create our own demons." It's so emphatically stated that we assume that director and star are writing the theme down with a sharpie for us and underlining it three times. 

When Stark mentions his own demons he's not talking about the demon in a bottle. Stark's battle with alcoholism from the comic book has never transferred over to the movies. But at least they've painted Tony Stark as an addictive personality: women, toys, material possessions, adrenaline, and, uh, Pepper Potts. He can't get enough of any of them. His latest addiction is non-stop tinkering with his suit and building multiple variations of the same. There's now an Iron Man for every occasion like Stark is Batman and the suits are merely Utility Belt. The Suit may be better than ever but Stark is falling apart inside it. His near-death in The Avengers has shaken him. Thankfully the man inside the man inside the suit is fully engaged. After what felt like coasting in Iron Man 2 and a little phoning it in with The Avengers (when other stars were around to pick up the slack) Robert Downey Jr seems to have woken up again to the blessing that this role has been to his career. 

That's a good thing since he spends most of this third film outside the suit. The first of the film's two gargantuan action setpieces robs him of the armor multiple times and blows it up real good, too. At times IRON MAN 3 plays like an absurd superheroic parody of MacGyver as Tony Stark battles impossibly powerful enemies without his usual protective gear. But fear not, the suit will return, as cavalry, in the last positively insane battle sequence. It's arguably too insane -- what the hell is happening? -- but it undoubtedly already earned this series its third Oscar nomination for Best Visual Effects. Still and all, the film's repeated abuse of the Iron Man suit, brings us to the movie's true or at least most deftly handled theme: Identity.

In that opening prologue at the science convention while the movie is writing the "we create our own demons!" theme in bold sharpie, this other more playful theme is already in place. It's scrawled right there as a joke on Tony Stark's chest, also with a Sharpie, on his sticky name tag...

You Know Who I Am" 

"We create our own demons" gets heavy handed and awkward at times -- particularly in the first half as The Mandarin (Ben Kingsley) begins to threaten America for its past sins. But the theme of identity is always lighter, funnier, and more skillfully organic to the story. The heroes (Iron Man, his sidekick War Machine, and his girl Pepper) are all struggling to redefine or at least refine their roles. Pepper's stunned reaction to her own actions in the finale is one of the best laughs in movie theaters this year. The film even finds a neat way to sidestep the racist history of The Mandarin villain (an arch-enemy created in the 1960s comics) by letting Ben Kingsley run with this theme as only a skilled character actor could.

Ben Kingsley's as Iron Man's arch-nemesis from the comic books "The Mandarin"

Like most noisy visual extravaganzas, some details are already starting to fade but this is great popcorn fun. It's frequent twists and surprises and humor give it something like its own identity in the overly crowded superhero genre. I know what Iron Man 3 is: The best of the trilogy.


Grade: B+
*About the Title: "It's Iron Man Three... not 3. It's spelled out in the credits!" - purist geek
Oscar Chances: This should easily make it three-for-three with Visual FX nominations but given that it's so much better than the second film in the trilogy maybe it can compete for the Sound Editing nomination again like the first film?

Takeaway Question: Is this the first Marvel film to pass the Bechdel Test?
For those of you who are unfamiliar with the Bechdel Test it's a simple and simply brilliant pass/fail test of a movie's sexism. All that's required to pass is to have an onscreen conversation between two women that is not about a man. You'd think this would be easy but so many films fail, either by not having more than one female character (half the human race, filmmakers! step up your game) or never putting them in scenes together that aren't reductively about men. About halfway through this picture Pepper (Gwynnie) and Maya (Rebecca)  speak to each other... ALONE. And though they're thrown together because they both have slept with Tony Stark he is only the beginning of the conversation. They actually talk about scientific ethics! Well done, Shane Black. You've passed the test.

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (23)

Kiss Kiss Bang Bang was in my top ten for the last decade, and while this isn't on the same level, it's a big step up for the series. Black was definitely the right call.

May 5, 2013 | Unregistered Commentereurocheese

I met Gwyneth Paltrow on set! The movie was filmed very close to where I go to school, and I was an extra. She was soooo sweet, which I was maybe a little surprised by given the persona the media has created for her. And no, she never once brought up organic eggs or DeGournay hand painted wallpaper. ;)

I haven't seen the movie yet, but I can't wait, and I'm glad you enjoyed it. I really hope it doesn't outgross Titanic, though. Once was enough!

I didn't like this one at all, and I love the first two movies. It felt like Shane Black had no idea how to handle Iron Man and his world and had no respect for it. Sure, it was entertaining and funny but not a good story. And the super soldiers thing was beyond lame, IMO. It's also poorly paced and structured, and big plot points are resolved or not resolved like they didn't matter. I honestly felt a lack of respect for the fans.

May 5, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterSad man

You know it was great to see tony without the armor but what was up with the mandarin?? This role was hyped up forever and he turns out to be an actor??? Come on man you have to do better than that!!!!!!

May 5, 2013 | Unregistered Commentergene

James Badge Gale, guys!

May 6, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterWill h

Nat, out of curiosity, did you stay until the end of the credits to see the post-credits scene. It's not a necessary scene for the movie, but it is pretty funny (and has an appearance by a character I know you were a fan of (at least in that incarnation). By the way, I loved the twist with the Mandarin, mostly for how committed Ben Kingsley is to it (I haven't seen him have this much fun in a long time and I love it).

May 6, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterRichter Scale

The worst movie of the year so far. Come on, the screenplay was soo bad and the villain a b-rated story.

May 6, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterDaniel B.

Is anyone fed up with htis sort of film dominating,i enjoyed no 1 but no 2 was awful and this looks like more of the same although witha bit more time spent on the script,if i see one more plane falling out the sky or car blowing up i'm am gonna start eating my feet.