"The Landlord" at 50
Wednesday, May 20, 2020 at 7:09PM by Mark Brinkerhoff
50 years ago today the one and only Hal Ashby, then an Oscar-winning film editor (In the Heat of the Night, The Russians Are Coming! The Russians Are Coming!) made his directorial debut with the release of The Landlord. Based on a 1966 novel and starring an almost inconceivably baby-faced Beau Bridges, its plot is fairly run-of-the-mill today but must’ve seemed quite daring for the time: A young man named Elgar (?!), who comes from wealth and lives with his parents at their Long Island estate, decides to buy a “rundown” tenement house in the dicey, gentrifying neighborhood of Park Slope. (Imagine!)
The tenants are black, he’s white, and his scheme is to evict them all so he can convert the property into something posh—a vanity project, if there ever was one.
Things do not go according to (his) plan...
His landlord’s tenants take an instant disliking (or at least skeptical stance) to him. As Ashby knew how to cast a movie, they’re played by a powerhouse group of actors: Pearl Bailey, Mel Stewart, Louis Gossett Jr. and the luminous Diana Sands. The tension between tenants and landlord turn, slowly, into a detente. Connections tantamount to friendship form. Living conditions improve—for some more than others. Neighborhood hoodlums and run-ins fade. The landlord even enters into an interracial relationship with a light-skinned woman he meets at a club. All the while the landlord's disapproving family thinks him to be out of his mind and urges him to find a more suitable, reputable line of work.
This being a dramedy, the darker moments are interspersed with light, emanating largely from Lee Grant as Elgar’s mother. She plays it big and rather broad, but also has an endearing, drunken scene with a warm, inviting Bailey while visiting Park Slope.
And then there’s the fractured, discomfiting triangle of Sands, Gossett as her mentally unbalanced husband, and Bridges, whose Elgar has a one-night tryst that results in her character’s unplanned pregnancy. In these scenes are where Sands really shines. She’s poignant and heartbreaking; that she opts to have, then give up, Elgar’s baby, despite the disastrous effects it has on her husband’s fragile psyche, seems unreal but also a dynamite showcase for Sands’ gifts. How tragic that this talent, not even 40, died shortly after The Landlord was released. What a loss; one can only imagine the actressing Sands could’ve had in store.
It’s hard to overstate how incredible Ashby’s ‘70s run was, and still largely holds up today. An intuitive, sensitive director, he followed The Landlord with future cult classic, Harold and Maude (1971). Then, in quick succession, came the critically acclaimed The Last Detail (1973); and Oscar-winning successes Shampoo (1975), Bound for Glory (1976), Coming Home (1978), and Being There (1979). In fact, Ashby is one of only a handful of directors (including Elia Kazan, Martin Scorsese and William Wyler) to direct actors to Academy Awards in all four acting categories—a feat accomplished over the course of three films in just five years.
As with many, many films of its era, The Landlord can be an elusive watch. (It is on DVD and Blu-ray, and there’s a grainy, chopped up video of it floating around YouTube.) And, despite ending on a rather absurd note—you have to see a man madly driving a sports with a newborn in a suitcase in the passenger seat (!!!) to believe it—coupled with some questionable dialogue for modern audiences, The Landlord nevertheless remains a wild, worthwhile time capsule.
See it for the Ashby, Bailey, Lee and Sands of it all.
Related Article:
The Landlord was a big hit here when we held 1970 Supporting Actress Smackdown
Reader Comments (8)
Definitely a hell of a feature-film debut as I love Ashby's work in the 1970s as he was that decade's prominent filmmaker or one of them. I hope this film comes to Criterion as I would like to see some insight into the film.
I love this movie so much so thanks for writing about it again on the site. I really wish someone would stream it so more people could discuss. I think it's actually aged very well. It's definitely a lot more nuanced and provocative about race than MANY films that came after it.
"Ashby is one of only a handful of directors (including Elia Kazan, Martin Scorsese and William Wyler) to direct actors to Academy Awards in all four acting categories"
thanks for that excellent bit of oscar trivia - i had no idea
This has been on my “need to watch” list ever since the Supporting Actress Smackdown (I think?) where many people expressed confusion at Lee Grant receiving all the plaudits when both Diana Sands and Pearl Bailey are the MVPs...
I don't know how in all the smackdowning this went through it escaped me that Beau Bridges was the titular landlord. That only increase the "must see" category for me along with all the actressing.
I also want to see what NYC was like according to this movie.
Kermit -- i personally am not sure that there is a singular MVP of the movie. Diana Sands and Lee Grant are my favourites with Pearl Bailey in third but part of that is because Sands and Grant have the best characters to dig into. But in truth everyone in the film is marvelous. Ashby was a titan when it came to directing actors. So much great stuff in his movies. COMING HOME, SHAMPOO, THE LANDLORD, BEING THERE... i mean ensemble prizes all around, you know? HAROLD & MAUDE is less ensembley but still marvelous lead performances.
The Smackdown introduced me to this film and it's quickly become a favorite. However, I think we need to acknowledge the contributions of the film's writer, Bill Gunn. He was a fascinating figure in his own right and made some very interesting films (Ganja & Hess is an eerie, moody masterpiece) and he deserves to be more widely recognized. The authenticity that he brings to the film is invaluable.
I saw it recently and it holds up remarkably well They certainly got the look