Grammy Nominations: Choosin' Texas, Disrespectin' Madonna, Uplifting Tinashe, and More...
Monday, November 16, 2026 at 11:50AM by Nathaniel R
Madonna has her second best showing at the Grammy nominations... but it wasn't as much as "Confession II" deserved
As is our intermittent habit we like to share key Grammy nominations that intersect with the actors mediums of film, television, and stage. This year, there is a second major and motivating factor in talking about the Grammys; my queen Madonna (“The Queen of Pop” herself) had a shockingly great year. I was steeling myself for disappointment (the Grammys have always mistreated her) but hopeful. Sadly, the Grammys didn't shower her with honors. Still we'll always have her insanely large and awesome catalogue which is way more important. Even lifelong devout fans like myself didn’t suspect that she’d record one of very greatest albums 43 years into her justly iconic career. But “Confessions II” is a masterwork of a concept album, pulling you sensually, erotically, and inevitably into the ritualistic solitary/communal ecstacies of a night in the club that stirs up all sorts of memories and feeling, until you spill out into the early morning light of the day afterwards with more subdued but no less enthralling internal monologues about the ephemeral nature of life and love. I was basically giddy all summer, feeling like a teenager again in terms of ecstatic reaction to a new album from an idol. I truly think it's one of her top two albums of all time (the other being 1998's "Ray of Light", her only project to score an Album of the Year nomination).
More on the nominations after the jump...
My summer Madonna reveries and giddiness spilled over into reactions to music in general so I listened to a lot more music than usual this year, made discoveries, flirted with becoming an Atiny even though I'm way outside the target audience and age range, and paid a lot more attention to everything.
Part One
The Big Four General Categories
ALBUM OF THE YEAR
And the nominees are...
- Bruno Mars - The Romantic
- Ella Langley - Dandelion
- Olivia Dean - The Art of Loving
- Olivia Rodrigo - You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So In Love
- Phoebe Bridgers - Lost Weekend
- Raye - This Music May Contain Hope
- Rosalia - Lux
- Taylor Swift - The Life of a Showgirl
Among the albums that didn't make it in the end the three with the highest profiles in terms of pre-nomination buzz were Tame Impala's "Deadbeat", Noah Kahan's "The Great Divide", and Madonna's "Confessions II". Alas it wasn't meant to be for any of those three. In the end the Grammy voters just couldn't do without their two comfort blankets (Bruno Mars & Taylor Swift) and a default nomination for an album buoyed entirely by a mammoth single (Ella Langley's Dandelion) despite the critical acclaim for the three snubbed albums exceeding any of those!
The three albums I listened to the most this year were Olivia Rodrigo's You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So In Love, Kacey Musgraves Middle of Nowhere, and Madonna's Confessions II and while all of them received an Album nomination in their respective genres, only Rodrigo landed in the top category.
SONG OF THE YEAR
This award is for the songwriter but I've listed the performers for ease of recognition.
- "Berghain" - Rosalia, Berghain, Yves Tumor
- "Choosing Texas" - Ella Langley
- "The Cure" - Olivia Rodrigo
- "Hate That I Made You Love Me" - Ariana Grande
- "I Knew It I Knew You" - Taylor Swift
- "Man I Need" - Olivia Dean
- "Risk It All" - Bruno Mars
- "Where Is My Husband" - Raye
I didn't remotely expect they'd make it but I was rooting for submissions from Tinashe "Crash Out", Kacey Musgraves "Dry Spell", and Brandi Carlisle "Returning to Myself". I didn't expect to see Madonna's "Bring Your Love" here either but it's the one category where I wouldn't have voted for Madonna. Confessions II is a masterpiece -- zero skips -- but BYL is like only the 10th or 11th best song on the album.
SHOULD / WILL WIN: The lyrically clever and explosively theatrical "Where Is My Husband" or "The Cure" would make excellent winners but sadly I think the far more generic "Choosin' Texas" or "Man I Need" are the most likely.
RECORD OF THE YEAR
Grammy voters rarely make much of a distinction between these two categories, but sometimes the artists themselves force their hand by submitting different songs. This award is for the overall recording of the song (production, performance, etcetera) rather than the songwriting itself. So, for instance, covers of famous songs or live versions can be nominated here (not that they often are) but not in "Song of the Year".
- "Berghain" - Rosalia, Berghain, Yves Tumor
- "Choosing Texas" - Ella Langley
- "The Cure" - Olivia Rodrigo
- "Dracula" - Tame Impala with Jennie
- "The Fate of Ophelia - Taylor Swift
- "I Just Might" - Bruno Mars
- "Man I Need" - Olivia Dean
- "Where Is My Husband" - Raye
The list is nearly identical. Taylor and Bruno Mars campaigned different songs but were still nominated in both categories so the only true difference between the lists is that Record of the Year has "Dracula" from Tame Impala instead of "Hate That I Made You Love Me" from Ariana Grande from the Song of the Year list. Did Bruno and Taylor really need placement in both categories? Zzzzz. (Tinashe submitted "Melatonin" here which is better than half of these but was never really in this conversation.)
SHOULD WIN / WILL WIN: Rooting for "Berghain" or "Where Is My Husband" but BLARGH I think it'll be "Choosin' Texas or "Man I Need".
BEST NEW ARTIST
- Angine De Poitrine
- Don Toliver
- Ella Langley
- Geese
- Remi Wolf
- Sienna Spiro
- Slayyyter
- The Womack Sisters
Major surprises here were Angine De Poitrine, Remi Wolf, and The Womack Sisters all of whom I spotted on zero prediction lists at the major awards sites. The surprise "snubs" if you can call it that (there were 331 eligible artists) include Role Model, Sam Fender, and brother and sister solo artists Malcolm Todd and Aubrey Hobart. Nevertheless the race is expected to boil down to Ella Langley vs Sienna Spiro.
Ella Langley and Don Toliver, both of whom have been around for quite some time, benefitted from the Grammys often confusing, highly political, and ever-changing definition of "new". In fact, Ella directly benefitted from a rule change allowing four submission in this category (it used to be only three). They changed the rule this summer and it feels like they changed it just so that they could include her here to be quite honest. Behind the scenes shenanigans are frequent in awards lands but particularly fishy with the Grammys when compared to other awards bodies.
Rising artists who could theoretically have scored here (if they submitted) included but were definitely not limited to Sinners star Miles Caton, controversy-laden Stella Lefty, K-Pop band Cortis, gen Alpha star Freya Skye, the delightful Holly Humberstone, the rowdy Kneecap (who were introduced to many a year back with their Oscar-submitted Irish film), a movie star's son in Magnus Ferrell, the critically acclaimed Underscores, and the 80s vibes of Haute & Freddy. Months ago it felt like Adela of "Aint in LA" and "Nicole Kidman" fame was a threat to win this category but she opted not to submit to the Grammys this year; she'll try to land in all four general categories at the next Grammys since "Prima" came out after the deadline for this season's awards so all her hits can be eligible next time around if not submitted this time.
Part Two
Film, TV, and Stage Prizes Because Those Are Our Primary Interest at TFE
BEST MUSIC FILM
- Billie Eilish: Hit Me and Hard and Soft - Billie Eilish, James Cameron, etc...
- EPIC: Elvis Presley in Concert - Baz Lurhmann, etc...
- Lilith Fair: Building a Mystery the Untold Story - Ally Pankiw, Dan Levy, Christina Piovesan
- Man on the Run - Paul McCartney
- To Be Celestial vs That's the Weight of the World - Earth Wind & Fire
This is the first Grammy nomination for James Cameron so if the Billie Eilish concert film wins he is only a "T" away from the EGOT since he has 1 Emmy and 3 Oscars already.
This is the 5th Grammy nomination for Baz Luhrmann which makes sense since his films are so often music-focused. But alas he doesn't have an E, G, O or T yet. He has been nominated for Grammys, Oscars, and Tonys but has yet to win any of the biggest showbiz prizes. How crazy is that?
This is the first Grammy nomination for Dan Levy who already has Emmys so if Lilith Faith wins he'll have the E and the G of the EGOT.
Very disappointed that Madonna's incredible jaw-dropping "Confessions II: The Film" was left off the list but kind of relieved that they skipped Taylor Swift's The Eras Tour movie. I am not a Swift hater and find the hate as boring as the obsessive fandom but seriously. No matter what organization you are you do not have to award the same person over and over and over and over again while ignoring other brilliant people.
BEST MUSIC VIDEO
- "Berghain" - Rosalia
- "Click Clack Symphony" - Raye feat Hans Zimmer
- "Hate That I Made You Love Me" - Ariana Grande
- "Lost Boys" - Phoebe Bridgers
- "Storm" - Gener8ion and Yung Lean
A disappointing category. Other great eligible contenders included "Dry Spell" from Kacey Musgraves, "Bring Your Love" from Madonna, "Dracula" from Tame Impala and "Madwoman" from Laufey. I was rooting for "Bad" from Ateez to surprise. The latter reportedly did submit in this category but not in Asian Pop Performance which most of the major K-Pop bands avoided following BTS' smart decision to boycott an ill-conceived category.
SHOULD WIN: "Berghain" is a masterpiece of a music video -- if anything else wins I will be furious though of course "Storm" is also a really interesting MV.
BEST MUSICAL THEATER ALBUM
- Chess the Musical
- The Lost Boys
- Ragtime
- Schmigadoon
- Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Given that Principal Vocalists are included in these Grammy nominations (as well they should be) this means Ana Gasteyer (Schmigadoon) and Tony winner Ali Louis Bourzgui (The Lost Boys) have scored their first Grammy nominations!
For those who are counting this category brings second Grammy nominations to Chess stars Lea Michelle (previously nominated for "Don't Stop Believin'" from Glee) and Tony winner Aaron Tveit (previously nominated for "Moulin Rouge! The Musical") and Ragtime's Tony winners Joshua Henry (previously nominated for "Carousel") and Caissie Levy (previously nominated for "Caroline or Change"). So if Chess, Ragtime or The Lost Boys wins Aaron Tveit, Joshua Henry & Caissie Levy, or Ali, respectively, will have both the G and T in the EGOT but they'll all have to step up their film and television work if they want to go for the E or the O.
Tony winner Shoshana Bean (The Lost Boys) previously won this category with "Hell's Kitchen"
BEST COMPILATION SOUNDTRACK FOR VISUAL MEDIA
- The Devil Wears Prada 2
- Stranger Things Season 5
- Wicked For Good
- The Wizard of Oz at Sphere
- Wuthering Heights
Strange line-up but I'm happy for Charli XCX's Wuthering Heights efforts to land here.
BEST SCORE SOUNDTRACK FOR VISUAL MEDIA
- The Odyssey - Ludwig Goransson
- One Battle After Another - Jonny Greenwood
- Project Hail Mary - Daniel Pemberton
- Star Wars: The Mandalorian and Grogu - Ludwig Goransson
- Widow's Bay - David Fleming
BEST SONG WRITTEN FOR VISUAL MEDIA
- "House" - Charli XCX (Wuthering Heights)
- "I Knew It I Knew You" - Taylor Swift (Toy Story 5)
- "Need Someone" - Andrew Bird (The Pitt)
- "No Place Like Home" - Cynthia Erivo (Wicked: For Good)
- "Runway" - Lady Gaga & Doecchi (The Devil Wears Prada 2)
A mildly surprising list. Choosing "No Place Like Home" when "The Girl in the Bubble" was right there (if you had to have a Wicked entry) is a... choice. I continue to be pissed that "Salt Then Sour Then Sweet" by Sara Bareilles and Brandi Carlisle keeps getting passed over. First the Oscars and now the Grammys. The injustices pile up.
Part Three
- Madonna's Other Categories
While Madonna's nomination total was much smaller than we had hoped (and many pundits had predicted) she did break a record... maybe. She has now been nominated at least once across five consecutive decades which is a record (we think -- waiting on verification).
Sadly Madonna was left out of not just the big three categories but Pop Solo performance, too (She had entered "Love Sensation" there). Instead the Recording Academy simply rubber stamped all their AOTY / Song/Record nominees in that category yet again skipping submissions from Madonna ("Love Sensation"), Tinashe ("Crash Out"), Lady Gaga ("Dead Dance"), Slayyyter ("Brand New Chanel$"), Role Model ("High Hopes"), and Charli XCX ("Dying For You") -- the most surprising omission though was Taylor Swift who landed a nomination for Record of the Year for "Fate of Ophelia" but somehow missed the somewhat parallel but less coveted Pop category. What's the point of having 100s of categories if you just nominate the same songs in each of them?
BEST POP DUO / GROUP PERFORMANCE
- "Bring Your Love" - Madonna and Sabrina Carpenter
- "Click Clack Symphony" - Raye featuring Hans Zimmer
- "Dracula" - Tame Impala and Jennie
- "Life of a Showgirl" - Taylor Swift and Sabrina Carpenter
- "Runway" - Lady Gaga and Doecchi
Sabrina Carpenter is the star of this category, with two nominations. I have no idea who will win this category since the nomination count was underwhelming overall for both Madonna and Tame Impala who had previously looked like potential winners here. Maybe Raye given how much she overperformed across all categories?
BEST DANCE / ELECTRONIC RECORDING
- "Crank" - Slayyyter
- "I Feel So Free" - Madonna
- "Lights Burn Dimmer" - Fred Again
- "Melatonin" - Tinashe
- "Music" - Underscores
- "My Old Ways" - Tame Impala
Solid list here. Hoping the win goes to Madonna but "Melatonin" is also superb.
BEST DANCE POP RECORDING
- "Blue Moon" - Zara Larsson
- "Dance" - Slayyyter
- "Danceteria" - Madonna
- "Life Boat" - Raye
- "Too Easy" - Tinashe
Sad for Robyn's "Dopamine" which deserved a spot. If the winner isn't Madonna with the best or second best song from Confessions II (give or take "School") I will be furious.
BEST DANCE / ELECTRONIC ALBUM
- Madonna - Confessions II
- Robyn - Sexistential
- Skrillex - Soma
- Slayyyter - Worst Girl in America
- Tame Impala - Deadbeat
Missing the boat here were Underscores "U" and Nine Inch Nails latest among others. Rooting for... You guessed it. Madonna won this category previously for Confessions on the Dancefloor twenty years back. Having its sequel also win would be... correct.
BEST REMIXED RECORDING
- "Beto's Horns (Fred Remix)" - Fred Again
- "I Just Might" (Austin Millz Remix)" - Bruno Mars
- "Love Sensation" - Madonna & Kylie & Stuart Price
- "Opalite (Chris Lake Remix)" - Taylor Swift
- "A Question of Trust (Boyz Noize Remix)" - Boys Noize
- "Where Is My Husband!" - Raye
Madonna has won a paltry 7 Grammys across her career
- "Madonna Blonde Ambition World Tour Live" - Best Long Form Music Video (1992)
- "Ray of Light" - Best Short Form Music Video (1999)
- "Ray of Light" - Best Pop Album (1999)
- "Ray of Light" - Best Dance Recording
- "Beautiful Stranger" - Best Song Written for Visual Media (2000) --- one of her MANY Oscar snubs in their parallel category
- "Confessions on a Dance Floor" - Best Dance/Electronic Album (2007)
- "The Confessions Tour" - Best Long Form Music Video (2008)
How did your favourites fare this morning?



Reader Comments (1)
The Grammys are the least reputable of the EGOT prizes, but at least they sometimes correct the Oscars' arguably even worse music branch from time to time. "Beautiful Stranger" was one of those instances for sure. I definitely don't think Madonna would have won over Phil Collins that year (though the winner really should have been Aimee Mann), but a nomination should have happened. Alas, they had already succumbed to their bizarre Diane Warren fixation.