Venice: Angry Filmmakers, Smoking Lights, Disappointing Films
Wednesday, September 7, 2011 at 4:38PM [Editor's Note: Manolis, our correspondent from Greece, is wrapping up his time in Venice. But hopefully he'll go out on a higher note that this day, which disappointed him. -Nathaniel R]
The last two days were bad days for me at the festival. Films I had high hopes for proved to be less that satisfying and smaller films that I hoped would surprise me didn't.
People Mountain, People Sea
This was the ‘surprise film’ of the Competition section of the festival announced just a few minutes before its first press screening. But this was not the only surprise for the press attending. Halfway through the film smoke started coming out of a headlight in the screening room and many journalists started running towards the exits panicked. The screening was interrupted, the firemen came and fixed the problem that could have resulted in a fire. After 25 minutes the screening resumed and the remaining critics watched the rest of the story. The movie is about a man Lao Tie in a small province of China who realizes that the local police force are unable to catch his younger brother’s killer, so he decides to do it himself. He embarks a journey that not only brings him face to face with the killer but also brings out all the fears and anger hiding inside him for many years. Unfortunately the fire incident was far more interesting than the film. I would say that this was the worst film I saw in the festival thus far, if it wasn’t for...
4:44 Last Day on Earth
In a large New York penthouse a couple of lovers (William Dafoe & Shanyn Leigh) are spending their last night talking and making love. Tomorrow at 4:44 pm the world will come to an end. Director Abel Ferarra's (Bad Lieutenant, Dangerous Game, Mary) new film, which describes the way this couple faces the impending collapse of the world it thematically interesting (Don McKellar made a fine film on the topic with “Last Night” in 1998) but the potential is never fulfilled. What Ferrara has to offer is ideological deliriums and a cheap morality lessons.
Both Dark Horse by Todd Solondz and Himizu from Sono Sion were also nothing to write home about. The former started off promising but soon fell into the same category as nearly all of Todd Solondz's films: not exactly a failure but nowhere near the quality of his masterful Happiness (1998). The latter film, from Japan, was advertised here in Venice as one of the first films to deal with the Fukushima catastrophy but its use of the shots of the tsunami's aftermath played more like a marketing device than an essential or important part of the story. The average acting didn’t help either.
Wuthering Heights
The biggest disappointment for me was Andrea Arnold's newest film. I've been a fan since Red Road and especially loved Fish Tank so I expected that her new film would be absolute festival highlight, rather than just a good film with intriguing elements. She gambled on unknown and teenage actors in the leading roles which was gutsy but doesn't always pay off. The story is told from Heathcliff’s point of view, but unfortunately we never understand his very complicated relationship with Catherine. Worse Catherine comes off as a very unlikable and it's hard to understand how two men both become so obsessed with her. The cinematography is the standout element in the film, with Robbie Ryan (who lensed both Red Road and Fish Tank) delivering truly exceptional work. Arnold reveals a strange obsession with mud and with hanged puppies and though her angry filmmaking is fascinating it doesn’t suit this kind of film. It’s not that her black teenage ex-slave Heathcliff is the problem but it feels rather strange when he says, in the true Bronte fashion, “F*ck you, you c*nt”. It’s an original approach for sure but, for me, an experiment that could lead to future greatness but doesn't do so here.
Reader Comments (6)
In some ways, I feel like Venice this year really didn't have a consensus choice for best film, and that's really exciting (based on all the reactions I've read). Wuthering Heights is probably the movie I'm anticipating most coming out of Venice based on some of the reactions, but there are just as many people who didn't like it.
Thanks for the write ups, Manolis.
As with RJ, I have to say I'm anticipating Wuthering Heights too, even moreso because of the conflicting reports. Consensus choices always drive expectations way too high.
"hanged puppies"? Oh my! This looks bleaker than I thought it'd be.
Thanks, again Manolis!
Thanks Manolis, I've been loving your posts. Great to hear your take on 'Wuthering Heights'. I came out of 'Fish Tank' feeling admiration but also disappointment; I'd expected to love it. But it stayed with me and is one of my fave films of that year now. I expect from the clips that WH will be similarly unnerving.
Eeeeek. It sounds like I'm gonna HATE Wuthering Heights reading that write-up. It has way too many thing I cannot stand in lit adaptations. I'll see it, of course, but I really loved Fish Tank and Wasp so we'll see. Also, small rumours are saying Arnold was not happy with the film. Apparently, it was hell to make and just didn't come together the way she intended.
Oh, Todd Solondz. Is it ever gonna happen again with you?
Manolis -- thanks for your much appreciated time and energy into reporting this for the rest of us!
I'm starting to worry about Wuthering Heights. I like that Anrea Arnold took a very different approach from everyone else, but many people seem to point out that it doesn't transfer the passion, only the anger of the central relationship. If that's true, then it's a serious problem