Smackdown '72: Jeannie vs Eileen vs Susan ...with Geraldine Page and Shelley Winters
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/14b5d/14b5d0936f61329e85331f2f71475b5a52f9007f" alt="Date Date"
An overprotective mother, a vain social butterfly, a swimming grandmother, a newlywed, and a barfly walk into an Oscar ceremony...
Geraldine Page did not attend the ceremony but the rest were there.
The 1972 supporting actress Oscar lineup is quite literally a singular group. It's the only one in all of Best Supporting Actress history to feature not a single Best Picture nominated film. There's always at least one Best Picture represented. Not so in 1972. Even The Poseidon Adventure missed that top category despite 8 nominations in total.
The panelists and part one of the Smackdown after the jump...