Noirvember / Contrarian Corner: Motherless Brooklyn
By Lynn Lee
Is Motherless Brooklyn just another high-profile Oscar hopeful turned dud-on-arrival? The early signs for Ed Norton’s long-gestating passion project have not been encouraging, to put it mildly. Reviews on both the festival circuit and the film’s general release and here at TFE have been tepid, the box office even more so. Its awards prospects are pretty much nil. It’s also not the kind of movie that’s likely to find success through word of mouth or build a long-term cult following, and its chances of future critical reevaluation are uncertain at best.
All of which makes me a little sad, because I quite enjoyed the film, and think Norton deserves more credit than he’s getting for what he’s accomplished...