From the Vaults: Meryl Streep in "A Prairie Home Companion"
Thursday, June 9, 2016 at 12:13PM Since today marks the 10th anniversary of the release of Robert Altman's swan song A Prairie Home Companion (2006), a gem excavated from that year's Oscar blogging for those who were not around in 2006. Though I know I've cooled on Meryl in the years since I wrote this (2006 was a major peak for Meryl but too many performances that didn't thrill followed and were automatically exalted and Oscar nominated anyway) I consider her past decade a valley rather than a downward trend. All performers have their peaks and valleys. I'm waiting for the next transcendent performance -- Impatiently, but I promise I'm hopeful.
It didn't take Meryl Streep long. By 1987 at the very latest, just ten years into her career, we knew that she could do everything. We'd already heard the accents, seen the funny, witnessed the sexy, fallen in love, had our hearts broken and heard the magnificent singing voice. If she were less endearing and emotionally attentive as a performer her technical range would be just hateful, a thing to curse as she popped up again and again in films. But this woman has it all. She is, put simply, the most consistent versatile actor in the movies.
So what is there left for Meryl Streep to do? It turns out quite a lot...
The joy of watching her now, thirty plus years into a great filmography, is seeing which actors' muscles get flexed for each new project and seeing which past performances are its predecessors. There's also a communal thrill in watching her surprise both herself and us in each performance since there's nothing left to prove. Can you name another movie star who so regularly seems to be having a grand ole time while they're acting? Can you name another actor who is so technically accomplished but still regularly manages moments that feel spontaneous onscreen? I can't.
I've seen nearly all of her filmography which could explain why I prefer her comedic work. There's less of it so you have to hold it closer. Plus the thing I love most dearly about Meryl Streep (her joy in acting) bubbles right to the surface when she's asked to joke about. The Streep performance I cherish most on a personal level is her work in 1990's Postcards From The Edge wherein she also joked, sang, and played an entertainer. And all of this, if you'll excuse the breathless intro, is a very long way of saying that I was thrilled to see her comedic and musical chops get a work out again as "Yolanda Johnson" in A Prairie Home Companion .
Yolanda (Streep) is part of a singing group "The Johnson Girls" that once had more members but now includes just herself and her sister Rhonda (Lily Tomlin). For the first half hour of the film we get to know Yolanda in a series of brief sequences backstage. In the first she enters the theater where A Prairie Home Companion will hold its last broadcast (please note: this is a fictional film about the still running radio program) with her sister and daughter (Lindsay Lohan). She is holding too many things and nattering incessantly mostly to herself but ocassionally to others. Streep gives her character a quick easy laugh and a fluid temperament. As this sister act prepares for the show, Streep fills you in on the rest of Yolanda.
Yolanda's body language is a little fussy but also slow and open. She's often got her arms outstretched. She has a welcoming folksy presence but you get the immediate sense of fatigue from both age and a life on the road. There's also a weird dichotomous specificity of feeling that Yolanda is both a nervous girl and an old woman entirely at ease with her lot in life. Regarding the latter: several verbal remarks indicate otherwise but Streep plays them more like canned instinctual responses; They come from the character's simple humor and are uttered primarily for her sister Rhonda's benefit.
It's Rhonda who harbors more illwill toward their showbiz history. The famous Altman overlapping dialogue aids Lily and Meryl in detailing this sister act. Yolanda and Rhonda have spent their entire lives together and the actresses ably sell this. They're constantly talking to each other, but it's a well rehearsed decades-long togetherness: their minds are free to float elsewhere knowing that they'll always return to one another.
Yolanda's primary concerns are her death-obsessed daughter (whom she clearly worries about but takes joy in) and Garrison Keillor, the host of the show. You realize through her shift in demeanor with the host that she has either loved or romanced him before the events of the film takes place --Streep shows you this with simple glances even before the dialogue confirms your suspicions. She makes this dead romance her best running gag in the film, mining it for abundant laughs that a lesser actor wouldn't even know where to find let alone amplify.
By the time Streep hits the stage you're already completely aware of this woman's personality and her circumstantial simplicity (this life as a midlevel sister act is the only life she's ever known.) And, then in her vocal performances onstage she just keeps on deepening those initial impressions while giving a musical performance, full of idiosyncratic feeling and beauty.
As in all the best ensemble pictures, the performances of other actors inform each individual turn as well. In a great moment backstage Yolanda, realizing Rhonda is upset about a story they've been retelling, sings an old familiar tune and embraces her sister. When the tune ends, Rhonda tearfully says "singing is the only thing that ever puts me right". She's talking about herself but in Meryl's exuberant, silly, and vocally powerful stage performance that follows, you realize the same is true for her. They're peas in this showbiz pond. Singing also puts Yolanda right.
In so many melancholy and bittersweet ways Robert Altman's last film was a farewell. Casting America's most enduring Great Actress in this role made it sweeter. In the film's last scene the sisters and friends gab around a table about the departed radio show. Yolanda, giggling and reminiscing, is determined to jumpstart a farewell tour...
I love doing that last show. I just wanna do one last show and then another until I'm in a wheelchair. I just wanna keep doing 'em.
The Angel of Death (Virginia Madsen) enters this final sequence and smiles benevolently at these principal players corking Yolanda's infectiously loud joy. You realize immediately that one day all of us will give our last performance. One day all of these actors will be gone, even this beloved goddess of the cinema. Feel free to tear up. It's a testament to the film that the feeling is still somehow a good one.
Meryl Streep is now in her mid sixties. She's been knocking performances out of the park for nearly 40 years on the screen. She'll keep giving one last great performance until they put her in a wheelchair. She's gonna keep giving 'em.
Reader Comments (18)
Very nice. The Queen. I do hope she keeps working in various capacities (theatre, long-form television, 3-D movies, in whatever entertainment platform the future holds). You hit the nail on the head: she has had such longevity because she really seems to enjoy her work.
It's the only Meryl performance I have never seen.
Streep is happy because she's the only American actress in film who has lifetime job security. Everyone else can and will be thrown to the wolfs.
Mark-get on it! It's terrific. Also, bravo for getting through a couple of the 2007 titles.
I watched Bridges of Madison County the other day and realized that, save The Hours, Meryl hasn't given a truly great straight-dramatic performance in over twenty years. I wish she'd consider something other than comedy, for risk of becoming Helen Mirren in her golden years.
I have not seen anything holding back Maggie Smith or Judi Dench. John Gielgud worked consistently into old age. Nicole Kidman has worked in show business for 33 year. Maybe you just have to be likable and professional. It's not a bad gig.
It's a GREAT ensemble film. So much fun, but with a serious tone also. Everything well balanced. A perfect swan song for an american master director (who had also hits and flops).
I love Meryl. I will repeat it until my last breath. She's just a joy to look at, even or actually especially the last years, with all the critics. She never gave up. She goes her way and I'll be there following it no matter what.
Nat
I know you have cooled on her, but there is no one who has been able to sustain and be so multi-talented in the entertainment ... in my lifetime.... some of your and my favorites have definitely hobbled to the finish line.
I love her as a n actress but more importantly as a human being.
Marvin's Room,One True Thing,Music Of the Heart,It's Complicated are 4 normal per se performances by her
I've seen them all, and without question the most painful to watch were:
House of the Spirits
The Giver
Evening
Lions for Lambs
Hope Springs
My favorites:
Sophie's Choice
The Iron Lady
Silkwood
Julie and Julia
The Hours
Finally, the TV flims:
Angels In America
Holocaust
First Do No Harm.
Icon and legend. I hope she's planning more interesting projects.
I loved each and every word of this post, thank you Nathaniel for expressing why Meryl Streep is such a delight and joy to many of us. She is like Ella Fitzgerald, always ready to sing, and give life to another brilliant interpretation. Streep literally riffs on what she has done before. Her fluidity, versatility, excellence separate her out from other actors.
Also, she encourages and always takes just as much joy in her fellow performers.
It's sad that Robert Altman passed away, but at least his last film was wonderful and it contained Yolanda and Rhonda. Thanks again for a great article.
Just watched Postcards again, and it's one of her most free and easy turns and still manages to pulse with an undulating undercurrent of passion and mystery. Her memorable chemistry with Shirley MacLaine is yet another example of her joy and generosity in collaboration.
I love this movie. I love when Meryl sings without shouting. I honestly don't understand why was so widely ignored. It was pretty clear that it was Altman's swan song.
As a final film, it's a fitting one for Altman and Meryl rose to the occasion and more as it is one of Robert Altman's essential films.
I wouldn't exactly call this phase of Meryl's career a 'valley'...there have been some memorable performances like Julie & Julia, August Osage and Ricki & Flash. And I admire her for doing critically-panned movies like Mamma Mia and Iron Lady for the sheer act of flexing different acting muscles.
She's also contemplating semi-retirement according to a few recent interviews so we may not see her much in the coming years, and she's taking an exceedingly long break after filming Florence Foster Jenkins last summer (and getting the best reviews of her late career from UK critics for the latter).
I adore this movie and the Johnson sisters. Folks can say what they want, but she certainly has the light; endlessly watchable in every scene in every movie, even when she's hamming it up. (agree that House of the Spirits was def the WORST, but maybe it was more about the ridiculous casting choices and one of the most horrible adaptations of a novel in the last 25 years.)
I think Meryl may be looking for something on TV, which would be great. Lately my adoration of her has been completely usurped by the sublime acting talents and watchability of British TV star, Sarah Lancashire, in Happy Valley, and to a lesser degree, in Last Tango in Halifax.
Now I have to watch the clip of Meryl and Lily introducing Robert Altman's Honorary Oscar for the 500th time.
Absolutely love this!❤️